Three Down

Of the four classes I am taking this semester (three one-hour classes and one three-hour class), I have finished the work in three.  That means I have just one more class to finish, and I will be done with the semester.  Hopefully I can tidy that up this weekend and finish early.

I expect to earn A’s on my grade report.  I have been able to keep up with my grades online through Blackboard and a separate interface the ITMA program uses for grade reporting and assignment submission (having three different interfaces to work with is clunky and is something I think the program needs to address).  Three of the A’s I expect to earn really don’t mean much to me.  I did a modest amount of work to earn them.  In the case of one class, the assignments were a waste of time.  I can’t say I learned a lot.  In one class, I worked quite hard and feel proud of the A because it was not easy to earn.  I also feel I learned a lot in that class.

You know, I really, really hate grades.  I have been thinking about writing a book about assessment and grades.  Grades are a subject that interest me a great deal.  I hate the fact that grades are what motivates some students to learn — that unless there’s a grade attached, it isn’t worthwhile to some students.  I hate it that I spend a long time on feedback and some students turn to the grade and ask why did I get this? instead of reading the feedback, which would make the grade clear.

I really like working with my students, and it’s so exciting when I can tell they’re truly interested in something, and they want to learn it for the sake of learning it.  I find it frustrating that no matter how engaging my lessons might be (not every day, probably, but I hope they are most of the time) that some students will never be motivated by anything other than a grade.

A colleague of mine once described grades as both the carrot and the stick, and truer words were never spoken.  We use grades to punish kids who don’t do the work, and to reward those who do, even if they are only doing it for the grade.  I wonder what school would look like without grades.  I know it’s possible.  I know schools have done it.

I don’t know what made me go off on that rant.  I suppose I feel frustrated by my own school experience.  I have four A’s.  I worked to earn one of those A’s.  I didn’t learn much.  The grade doesn’t feel like much of a reward.  I’d rather have learned a lot.  For what it’s worth, I hear the program gets better.  Here’s hoping.  I am taking Principles of Instructional Design, Instructional Media, and Digital Audio next semester.

Related posts:

5 thoughts on “Three Down

  1. Grades are my biggest issue with education – as both a parent and a teacher. UC Santa Cruz originally did not give graves, the professor would write an evaluation. Currently they do issue grades but include an evaluation as well. This holds more weight within the University.

  2. Im just sad because some jobs available are mostly dependent on your grades or class standing. I must say that it's not the basis of fulfilling the job

  3. Hi! What do you think of the pursuit of the IT degree? I am certified in English and thinking of getting the IT certificate. Do you think it's worth it, or is it better to just self-educate? Thanks for your help.

  4. Also in the ITMA program–I find myself exhausted from this semester, being a perfectionist. I also taught night school and worked full time; how in the world do you handle the work load? Bravo!

  5. Hi Brian! Thanks for stopping by my blog. And thanks for the Bravo! I don't know. I know I had very little free time, and I just plowed through. I am pretty determined, I guess. However, I will say that I didn't find the one-hour classes to be too much of a challenge. It was mainly a problem keeping organized, which I used my Mac Calendar to help me with. I put due dates for all the assignments on my calendar, and that way I was sure to stay on top of everything. On a couple of occasions, I turned something in late, but with this program, it didn't really seem to matter. I missed the deadline for the last Intro to IT assignment, but the instructor took it — I was worried about that one because she had posted a deadline, and I just plain forgot. No good excuse.

Comments are closed.